Blog Post

Reverse Diets - What are they?  Why would you do it?  Should you do it?

Derek Decater • Nov 28, 2018

When low calorie diets stop working...

There’s a new trend in the fitness world. Reverse dieting.

So what is it and should you be doing it?


To understand what a reverse diet is we first need to take a minute to think about why we would do it and who it’s for.


Instead of getting into the science and physiology let me tell you a story…


Let’s say you have a great job; a nice house and things are looking good for you.

You pay your bills and you put money into savings each pay check.

One day you walk into work to find out you’ve been let go.

In that moment it’s a devastating blow.

But after you let off some steam you think to yourself...

"You know what. I’ve been saving up for a while. I’ll be OK. It'll only be temporary and then I'll get back on my feet"

For the next couple months your life pretty much goes on like it did before except you aren’t headed to work anymore. Instead you're job searching from the couch.

You’re not worried. You're smart and talented at what you do. Eventually someone will start hiring and when they do you will be the right person for the job.


This goes on for a while.

Interviews, applications, more interviews but nothing is happening.

You realize you’ve got to cut back.


  • You stop shopping online.
  • You stop going out to eat.
  • You stop spending on those little “extra’s” you had become accustomed to.


All while thinking this will pass.

But it doesn’t.

You start missing bills.

It’s getting bad.

You start paying attention to when you leave the lights on…. Because that electric bill is too high.

You find yourself wearing warmer clothes in the house because you are trying to save on the heating bill.

You’re officially struggling….and yes… its real.


So how does this apply to a reverse diet?

How does this apply to chronic under-eating?


Try to think of your body as this balance between income and expenses. When things are running well there in balance. Everyone is happy, and life is peachy.

BUT…

What happens when you cut calories?

Well initially you’ll probably lose weight.

Because like when you had a good job you’ve got some reserves in the savings account.

Everything is still running just fine but its running on less. And in the body composition world that means some weight loss.

I’m sure you’ve seen this with yourself or your friends. A diet works….Then it stops.


But Why?


Well month after month you’re under your daily needs.

You are “in debt” nutritionally speaking.

And just like when you couldn’t find a job you eventually have to start shutting things down if it gets too bad.


  • But instead of turning the heat off - Your body slows it metabolism to conserve energy.
  • Instead of turning off the lights - Your body down regulates hormones
  • Instead of not eating out - Your body physically slows you down. You move less so you don’t burn calories that are so badly needed.


Your body is officially in the “Oh shit” mode.


And it’s doing exactly what it should… its cutting expenses and trying to save wherever it can.

And here’s the problem I see most.

If you are trying to lose weight what do you do?

You cut more calories

Bad idea if your body is already slowing things down.

Just like if you lost your job the solution isn’t to keep spending. That won’t fix anything.

The solution is to start making some money! Or for us…start eating enough calories to allow your body to turn the lights back on.

It’s one of the hardest and most frustrating situations you can be in.

It’s so easy to tell yourself that because you aren’t losing weight that you need to cut more calories and move more.

But it’s just putting you further and further into debt. And your body isn’t having any more of it.


OK great. So what should you do?


Here’s how you get out of debt and get back to losing weight when everything has stalled.


First – it all comes down to calories. Calories are king no matter what you’ve heard on the internet. Track for a few days and see how many calories you typically take in. I suggest doing at minimum 7 days, so you get a full weeks’ worth of data.


(don’t fall into the trap of only tracking your good days. A bad weekend can skyrocket your average weekly intake numbers)


Second – figure out what your body needs to survive. This is your BMR or your resting metabolic rate. Think of it this way…. This is the amount of money you would need to live the life you want.


Here’s a quick calculator - https://www.precisionnutrition.com/weight-loss-calculator


Third – take a look at the difference between your income and your expenses. If its big. Like way over 500 calories. Or if it’s been going on for a long time then it might be time for a reverse diet.


Lastly – How to reverse.


DO NOT make big jumps in calories. In our analogy above this would be great. Just throw a bunch of money into the savings account, get a new job and things would be rolling again. But in your body those big jumps in calories will just cause you to gain weight and fat.

Think of it this way --- You’ve dumped all these calories into a body that still has the lights and heat off. That’s a recipe for disaster and some serious frustration.

Instead make small, planned increases and track how things are affected.

A 5-10 % increase is a good place to start.

Preferably from quality food sources of course.

Do these every 2 weeks or so.


But how do I know if “my lights and heat are still off” you might be asking.


Start by journaling.

Measuring your biofeedback can be huge here.


  • How is your sleep?
  • How is your energy level?
  • Mental focus?
  • Strength in the gym?
  • Performance in your sport?
  • Hunger cues?

These are all things we track with our clients. Why?

Because it’s our clue into whether or not our body is starting to turn everything back on!

Once it is… you’re in a safe place to “actively” start dieting again.

Now the furnace is running, and we can make some progress!

But this time hopefully you have learned your lesson and stay away from the extreme calorie deficits and/or extreme calorie burning.


You’ve got to check you balance sheet people! For weight loss we want, and we NEED to be in debt BUT not so in debt that our body starts turning out the lights.


By Derek Decater 03 Feb, 2023
"Maximize Your Weight Loss Efforts with These Time-Saving Meal Prep Techniques
By Derek Decater 03 Feb, 2023
Unleashing the Power of Protein for Effective and Sustainable Weight Loss
By Derek Decater 11 Feb, 2020
We use the slideboard everyday at Decater Performance. It's versatile It's fun It's Challenging Its easy to modify It's the Swiss Army Knife of exercise equipment.
By Derek Decater 10 Feb, 2020
When athletes and parent first come into the gym the goals is almost always to increase speed, power and explosives. To get there, all of our athletes need to build a foundation of strength and stability. As an old coach once told me, "You don't want to put a new engine in a car with no brakes." Once athletes have the strength and stability to produce AND control power then the fun begins. The problem with building power in the weight room is that traditional exercises don't translate well to field sports. Both from a movement and mechanical perspective. But also from a physiological perspective. When your sport requires, sprinting, cutting, jumping, throwing, rotating etc the options are limited with the typical barbell and dumbbell. Also with traditional weight-room exercise the athlete spends more time decelerating than actually accelerating. Not what we want if our goal is to optimize power production. Enter the Medicine Ball. With the medicine ball, or anything that can be thrown, the athletes are able to accelerate all the way through an exercise. There's no need to slow the barbell or dumbbell down. They learn how to produce power from the ground up and transfer that energy efficiently. With a medicine ball you are also able to train power in planes that would be difficult with traditional weight room exercises. So... Grab a medicine ball, watch the video below and get to work.
By Skye MacLeod 02 Dec, 2019
I recently taught a beautifully hot and sweaty Pilates class, and as my clients were leaving the room - a yoga instructor entered the room eager to get ready to teach the next class. "Is this just Pilates?", she asked.
By Dustin Hassard 29 Jul, 2019
Exercise is fun, at least, it’s supposed to be. Many people think of exercise as a chore that involves going to a gym and lifting weights or using the cardio equipment. Understandably, that doesn’t appeal to most people. The good news is that exercise does not have to be a chore, a grind, an endless suffering, something you have to force yourself to do. Yes, there’s going be a little bit of that if you want to improve, but overall, if you don’t find some level of enjoyment in physical activity, it’s not likely to last and your health will suffer, or worse, you’ll be stricken with boredom.
By Jordan Harder 08 Jul, 2019
Normally I don't do this.. But I'm going to poke a little at some of the speed advice I've been seeing out there... Google speed drills, and you will see a list of all sorts of wacky drills and advice. Most speed advice you will see will fall into one of two categories. They either overcomplicate the speed situation. Or don't address the root of the issue.
By Jordan Harder 08 Jul, 2019
If you are struggling to perform better on the field or court... not seeing results from your training.... Stop looking for the program or supplement that will help your performance... You will only be wasting your time, energy and money... Because if you aren't taking care of this one thing you will ALWAYS be leaving performance on the table... This is one of the biggest issues I see affecting all athletes and those who are looking to improve performance...
By Jordan Harder 13 Jun, 2019
The simple answer is yes. It has been proven to boost physical and mental performance. Creatine has a ton of myths with it, which is surprising because it is the most researched supplement available. Like any supplement, if you are not working hard, and recovering harder it probably not for you. Make sure to dial in your sleep, nutrition, and hydration before adding it in. Creatine is produced in the body (liver, pancreas, and kidneys) but at extremely low levels. Other ways to add Creatine in your diet is through consumption of red meat. But 60% of people are deficient in Creatine. Creatine is a fuel source for short duration high-intensity movements. Think sprints, jumps, athletics and weight training. Here’s the quick version of how it works. ATP is the energy currency of the body. When used ATP splits into ADP + phosphate when used for energy. What Creatine does is bind with the phosphate so that it can be reused without tapping into the aerobic energy pathways. Creatine usage also has been linked to small increases in growth hormones such as IGF-1, which helps increase muscle mass. Creatine also has cognitive benefits. It has been linked to minimizing the effects of neurological diseases and brain injuries (concussions). As well as increase short term memory and memory recall. It is not a miracle drug or anything that will change your life. But it can be used to help slight boosts in performance. When taking Creatine there is no need to load initially. 5g a day is all you need. Make sure you are taking Creatine monohydrate. Creapure is the way to go, make sure the bottle has the Creapure logo on the back to make sure you are getting the highest quality available. I throw mine in my daily smoothie. --
More Posts

Join Our Newsletter and Never Miss New Content!

Share by: